Amanda Seyfried Auditioned for ‘Wicked,’ Sang with Cynthia Erivo, and Still Didn’t Get to Be a Good Witch

Buy Me A Coffee

GET ON THE LIST - ICONICHIPSTER.COM

Subscribe to IconicHipster.com ~ Receive daily posts plus list-exclusive content straight to your inbox:

We never spam.

Amanda Seyfried wanted to defy gravity, but the universe said, “Nah, sis.”

The 39-year-old actress recently spilled the tea on how she auditioned to play Glinda in the upcoming Wicked movies—only to watch the role float off in a giant pink bubble to Ariana Grande instead. Brutal.

Now, Amanda isn’t just some random Wicked hopeful who thought she could just waltz in and sing Popular—she actually has musical street cred. She starred in Mamma Mia, where she sang ABBA songs in picturesque locations while Meryl Streep emotionally twirled around her. Universal Pictures even moved Wicked’s original release date to make room for the Mamma Mia sequel. So Amanda was like, “Hey, maybe the stars are aligning for me to be the next Broadway-to-Hollywood princess.” Spoiler: They weren’t.

See also  Cynthia Erivo Declares War on Jonathan Groff’s Salivary Glands at the 2025 Tonys – It’s a Splash Zone, Baby! 💦🎭

Amanda’s Master Plan (That Did Not Work)
Speaking on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Amanda revealed that she was playing some next-level 4D chess, thinking the scheduling gods were on her side.

“I knew Wicked was happening because Mamma Mia 2 stole its release date,” she said. “So when that happened, I was like, ‘Okay, they’re pushing Wicked. That gives me time to manifest my Glinda era.’”

And she DID prepare. Amanda wasn’t about to half-step this. She trained her voice, she put in the work, and she hit those high notes like a woman on a mission.

See also  Jonathan Bailey Attends The 'Wicked' Premiere In Ruby Red Slippers And Wears A Poppy Pin

“I’ve never felt that solid in my voice,” she admitted. But apparently, Wicked’s casting directors were looking for someone just a little bit more… Arianic? (Is that a word? It is now.)

Still a Wicked Fan, Despite the Wound
Even though she didn’t get the part, Amanda is still an unshakable Wicked stan.

“We listen to ‘Defying Gravity’ every day,” she revealed. (Which honestly? Sounds emotionally exhausting, but okay.)

Also, silver lining—she got to sing with Cynthia Erivo, who is starring in the movie. And according to Amanda, that was a moment.

Was it enough to ease the heartbreak of not getting to be Glinda? Probably not. But hey, at least she got to duet with a Tony-winning goddess, and that’s not too shabby.

See also  Glinda's Masterclass: "Toss Toss" Like a Pro and Other Life Lessons from 'Wicked's Deleted Scene

Check out her full interview below! (And maybe send her a pink glittery care package, just in case she’s still feeling the loss.)

Comments area

Sidebar

Must Read

Sinead O’Connor’s Estate Demands Donald Trump Stop Using Her Music During Rallies

Sinead O'Connor's estate has put their foot down, throwing...

Simu Liu Releases New EP ”ANXIOUS-AVOIDANT’

Simu Liu just unleashed his EP, and guess what?...

Taylor Swift and Her Folks Spent Christmas at Travis Kelce’s Mansion

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce shook things up at...

‘Shameless’ Star Jeremy Allen White Shops for Thanksgiving Groceries

Jeremy Allen White is gearing up for a Thanksgiving...

Austin Butler Talks About Starring In ‘Pirates Of The Caribbean’ Reboot

Get ready for a swashbuckling saga involving none other...

Watch Ariana Grande’s Performances At The 2024 Met Gala Here

The 2024 Met Gala just got a sprinkle of...

Ellen and Portia: From Hollywood to Tea & Crumpets, Bye Bye USA!

Word on the cobblestone streets is that Ellen DeGeneres...

You Might Also Like

The Weeknd Drops $1 Million for Fire Relief—Literally Brings the Heat to Fight the Heat

When the world’s on fire—literally—you can count on The...

Nicole Kidman Slammed for Latest Instagram Post

In a world where even celebrating Aussie music for...

Flavor Flav Gets Schooled on Chappell Roan: “My Bad, Y’all!”

Flavor Flav, hip-hop’s original hype man and owner of...

Travis Kelce Reveals What He Gave His Teammates for Christmas

Travis Kelce, the wizard of gift-giving and tight end...

Katy Perry Previews Her New Song ‘Lifetimes’

Katy Perry is on a mission! She’s not just...

🚨BEYONCÉ DITCHES FLYING CAR FOR GOLDEN PEGASUS OF POWER—WORLD NOT READY🚨

So remember how Beyoncé was literally floating through the...