Looks like Hallmark’s got its own little Christmas miracle—Finding Mr. Christmas is coming back for a second season! Yes, you heard that right. The network known for its festive rom-coms and sweater-wearing protagonists has decided to double down on its first-ever reality TV series. Because why settle for mistletoe when you can have drama and glittering snow?
Hallmark confirmed to People (because where else would Hallmark spill tea?) that Mean Girls alum Jonathan Bennett will return to play Cupid, Santa, and a reality TV host all rolled into one, searching for the next big Hallmark Christmas movie hunk. Move over, Rudolph—the true star of Christmas might just be a guy in flannel who’s really good at holding mugs.
In Season 1, Bennett assembled a lineup of 10 would-be leading men, each vying for the coveted title of “Mr. Christmas.” The contestants tackled Hallmark-themed challenges ranging from decorating gingerbread houses with too much flair to delivering heartfelt monologues about small-town bakeries. Think The Bachelor, but with fewer roses and way more tinsel.
And of course, the show wasn’t all Bennett’s sleigh to pull. Judge Melissa Peterman joined him, along with a rotating cast of guest judges to determine which contestant had the “talent, heart, authenticity, and charisma” to headline Hallmark’s next Countdown to Christmas movie. That’s code for: who can make us swoon while pretending to fall in love with their childhood best friend in a snowstorm.
The ultimate prize? The winner gets to star in a Hallmark Christmas movie, meaning they’ve officially “made it” in the world of feel-good cinema. Forget Oscars—this is about standing in a snowy gazebo and making America believe in love again.
Season 2 promises even more holiday hijinks, heartfelt moments, and maybe—just maybe—a guy who can deliver the line “I didn’t know what I was missing until I met you” without laughing. Santa, we’re ready! 🎅✨